Untitled Document
Untitled Document
 

15. March 2005: The Compassion To Refute

 
Ted Morino
SGI-USA Vice General Director

1) Compassion is the essential spirit of the Daishonin’s refutation.

2) By sharing Buddhism, we embrace the Daishonin’s spirit of courage and compassion, which fueled his acts of refutation.

Question:Why does Nichiren Daishonin put so much emphasis on refuting other sects? What does this mean for people practicing today?

Answer: Buddhist teachings are intended to lead people to a state of unshakable happiness, and Nichiren Daishonin viewed the Lotus Sutra as the highest teaching. But the prevalent Buddhist schools of his time had strayed from that intent, denigrating the Lotus Sutra and becoming mired in esotericism and often either self-centered or self-denying practices.

Compassion is the essential spirit of the Daishonin’s refutation. It is not an arrogant act merely done for the sake of being correct. The Daishonin knew that distorted views of Shakyamuni’s teachings caused suffering. By speaking out he risked life and limb to clarify the way to enlightenment for all people.

SGI President Ikeda presents his understanding of the Daishonin’s four principle critiques of 13th-century Buddhist schools (June 2002 Living Buddhism, p.16). The Daishonin enumerates aspects of Buddhist practice that—in the sects he refuted—had grown disproportionate, overshadowing the balanced nature of Buddhist teachings. These are: 1) seeking salvation through the external power of an absolute being; 2) seeking to attain enlightenment only through the direct perception of one’s own mind and being content with that self-enlightenment; 3) seeking to gain benefit in this life through occult means; and 4) being controlled from without by means of precepts or regulations.

President Ikeda continues: “The perfectly balanced teaching does not succumb to any one of these extremes, but expounds the fusion of internal and external power as the means to transform the life of the individual as well as the surrounding circumstances. Combining internal and external power means discovering within the self a power that is greater than the self. This is what is referred to in the Daishonin’s teaching as ‘inherent’ and manifest’ Buddhahood, and it is the essence of Nichiren Buddhism.”

In other words, none of these extreme views of Buddhism will, on their own, bring about Buddhahood. Interestingly, though Nichiren was often criticized for being exclusivist in his view of Buddhism, it was in fact the schools he refuted whose concepts of Buddhism were too narrow and incomplete.

President Ikeda then contrasts the four extremes above with four more integrated viewpoints. These are: 1) the ability to embrace the sick and weary with the life-state of Buddhahood and provide a sense of peace of mind; 2) the ability to believe and actually sense that we posses within us the power to change ourselves; 3) the ability to courageously challenge our circumstances; and 4) the ability to control earthly desires and eliminate evil through our inner wisdom (June 2002 Living Buddhism, p.17).

Based on Nichiren Daishonin's compassion to refute erroneous teachings, how best can we respond to distortions that seek to separate practioners from the Law?
When we become stronger, wiser and happier people by clarifying the importance and power of our Buddhahood, it is only natural that other people will want to know what has changed and how we have improved. No one’s problems or misunderstandings are unique; someone else is certain to be suffering from the very obstacle we have overcome.

By sharing Buddhism, we embrace the Daishonin’s spirit of courage and compassion, which fueled his acts of refutation. The times and methods may change, but the desire to rid ourselves and others of suffering remains the central purpose of Buddhist practice.


Introduction
Monthly Study Materials
 
1. Buddhism in New Light Chapter 5: Faith and Freedom
2. Buddhism in New Light Chapter 4: What Love Is Not
3. Buddhism in New Light: Chapter 3:
The Way We See Ourselves
4. Buddhism in New Light Chapter 2: Violence Is Weakness, Prayer Is Power
5. Buddhism in New Light Chapter 1: The “Problem” of Faith
 
Soka Spirit Gosho Quotes
Reference Materials
Temple Issue Timeline
World Tribune
Living Buddhism
SGI-USA Newsletter
Justice Chronicle
Suggested Readings
Downloadable Materials
Untitled Document
Contact | © 2006 SGI-USA. All rights reserved.