Untitled Document
  5. What's the Real Victory We're Seeking in the Temple Issue?  
Jeff Farr
Associate Editor

For the last 12 years of the temple issue, SGI members have been talking about fighting the malicious and destructive forces of the Nichiren Shoshu - achieving victory in the temple issue.

But what exactly is this victory?

From talking to many SGI-USA leaders about this, I've learned that the real victory we're seeking is assuring that everyone in our organization and everyone in the temple organization - plus anyone else who is interested - is thoroughly educated about the difference between the fundamental spirit of the SGI and the distorted views of Nichiren Shoshu.

In other words, we want everyone to learn the difference between the correct and incorrect practice of Nichiren Daishonin's Buddhism.
It's important to understand that we are not seeking, in any sense, the unhappiness of Nichiren Shoshu members. We are instead seeking their happiness - their victory in their lives - through teaching them the correct understanding and practice of this Buddhism. Although both the SGI and the temple teach the chanting of Nam-myoho-renge-kyo, the two organizations' philosophies are completely at odds. For example, the SGI believes, as the Daishonin teaches, that all people are equal, that all people are essentially Buddhas. All people have the Law within. This Buddhism is thus centered on the ordinary person, and the SGI is spreading it with this clear understanding.

The current Nichiren Shoshu priesthood, though, doesn't see things this way. The temple believes that we are lesser beings than priests - especially the high priest, who has been set up as a supreme being. It's a priest-centered religion.

The priests teach in their study publication, Dai-Nichiren, that correct practice entails "absolute faith in and strict obedience to the High Priest." They ignore the Daishonin's strict assertion that we should follow not the person but the Law - that we should put the Law, not any high priest, in the center.

When the priesthood first excommunicated the SGI in November 1991, many SGI members felt that it was their responsibility as disciples of the Daishonin to educate people about the growing philosophical difference. This, we felt, was the same as educating people about what the Daishonin's Buddhism really is and is not, what it really teaches and does not teach.

In other words, this education was shakubuku, the spread of Buddhism. The true victory we seek in the temple issue is indeed found in this educational process - one that doesn't necessarily have a clear endpoint, similar to the kosen-rufu movement not having a clear endpoint; kosen-rufu just keeps going on eternally; so does this education. The temple issue raises this question: What does Buddhism posit as the greatest victory we can seek in our practice? Ultimate victory to the Daishonin was to make continual effort for kosen-rufu, to never give up. Our ultimate victory is when we've done our best, throughout our lives, to educate others and ourselves about this Buddhism. To help every person attain Buddhahood.
In "Repaying Debts of Gratitude," the Daishonin writes that "if Nichiren's compassion is truly great and encompassing, Nam-myoho-renge-kyo will spread for ten thousand years and more, for all eternity, for it has the beneficial power to open the blind eyes of every living being in the country of Japan, and it blocks off the road that leads to the hell of incessant suffering" (Writings of Nichiren Daishonin, p. 736). This is his heart, his goal, stated simply: to educate everyone about Nam-myoho-renge-kyo, to thus give everyone, "every living being," happiness. And to block off, once and for all, "the road that leads to the hell of incessant suffering," the road of incorrect teachings.

If we make this goal our own and do all that we can toward it, we win in life, we truly win.

(Originally published in the World Tribune, Feb. 12, 1999)

1. Does the Gohonzon Need an Eye-opening Ceremony?
2. How Can We Say for Sure That the SGI Is Right?
3. How Is Mentor-and-Disciple Taught Differently in the SGI and the Temple?
4. Shouldn't We Just Self-Reflect?
5. What's the Real Victory We're Seeking in the Temple Issue?
 
World Tribune
Living Buddhism
SGI-USA Newsletter
Justice Chronicle
Suggested Readings
Downloadable Materials
Untitled Document
Contact | © 2006 SGI-USA. All rights reserved.